Author: davidhiggerson

Why Cornwall isn’t the Capital of Clickbait…

aaeaaqaaaaaaaakiaaaajdu4ythmzjdkltllywitngiyyy1iota2ltnmywfkndhizta1za

It’s quite common to hear people denounce the work my colleagues do as ‘clickbait.’ Too common, in fact.

The sensible option, some would argue, would be to ignore it. After all, the facts tell a different story. And I’m going to give sharing the facts another go.

Why? Two reasons.

The first is that what started off as an unfounded criticism by those who disagreed with the approach to growing digital audience the company I’m digital publishing director at, Trinity Mirror, had decided to take appears to have become a received wisdom.

Take, for example, a sentence in a blog post written by an academic called Dan Evans on the OpenDemocracy blog. Having read the blog several times, I’m still not sure of the point it’s trying to make, but this sentence stood out:

(more…)

2016: Some of the people who helped shape regional journalism

impact

If there’s one thing journalism doesn’t need going into 2017, it’s another clutch of gongs. For an industry which is constantly facing negative headlines (often understandable, of course), we still do a great job of celebrating our achievements.

And if you cut beyond the headlines and the punditry, there is a lot to celebrate despite the massive challenges the industry faces, challenges many in the industry are tackling head on.

So it’s for that reason that I’ve come up with a list of the people or teams or brands I believe deserve acknowledgement for things done for the industry in 2016. Of course, it’s not exhaustive, there are people who I’ve bound to have missed out (sorry!), and I could just list all the great people I work with every day, but hopefully it paints a picture of some of the great things going on in the industry.

Over on holdthefrontpage, Steve Dyson listed his seven ‘regional heroes’ (for transparency purposes, I should probably point out I made his list in 2015), and this list is inspired by that idea. For me, the heroes of our industry are those fighting to make a difference within the industry through their own actions, attempting to inspire those around them, regardless of their role or seniority, at a time of great uncertainty. To that end, Alison Gow’s list of women to celebrate in 2016 makes for a great read. 

Some thoughts from me…

(more…)

The Christmas Eve front pages of 2016

As much a tradition in newsrooms as watching Home Alone, eating far too much and falling out of Monopoly all are at home (or is that just my house), the Christmas Eve front page is something planned in advance by most newsrooms and fought for by journalists in many too.

With Christmas falling on a Saturday this year, many regional Press titles (in my opinion) produced some of their most compelling front pages of the year, combining strong stories which carried a certain festive spirit alongside promos for other features in the often-larger weekend editions.

Of course, breaking news will always overtake even the most carefully-planned Christmas Eve front page, and you can see that happening in a few below.

And then there’s the Wolverhampton Express and Star which certainly ensured it was likely to be a talking point over Christmas Turkey in many Black Country homes on Christmas Day with its poll suggesting most people in the region regretted the vote for Brexit:

e-and-s

A front page to get the newsdesk phones ringing on Christmas Eve if ever there was one. “What it is, is….”

Anyway, here are the front pages I could find…

 

 

Local journalism will die if those who claim to champion a free Press get their way

As journalists, we pride ourselves at being good at knowing what people want to read, and good at getting them to read the things we feel they need to read.

However, getting people to show an interest in the processes of journalism, and the things which could damage the ability of journalists to keep the public in the know, is another story entirely.

But if you like your local newspaper, or at the very least appreciate the fact that there’s a local newsroom covering the things which matter to your community, then I implore you to read on.

Because local journalism is facing perhaps it’s gravest threat. 

(more…)

Maybe the solution to fake news lives on our sports desks

msc_2008-saturday2c_09-00_-_11-00_uhr-moerk001_sa

Many millions of words have been written about the scourge of fake news, and I’ve some bad news: I’m about to offer a few hundred more. But hopefully they will convey a point which hasn’t been discussed up until now.

Fake News isn’t new. The impact Fake News has had (if it can be proven) has maybe taken a new turn, but the scale of the problem isn’t new. Or at least it isn’t if you’re a sports reporter.

While many rightly lament the apparent inability of the public to separate fact from fiction (and certainly on my Facebook feed, those doing the lamenting were also in some cases also sharing some of the bogus Donald Trump stories just a few days earlier), few have offered realistic answers beyond ‘Blame Facebook’ and ‘Do something Facebook.’

(more…)

Why we need to tell readers about how we report the news

men-cricis

If you were to list the changes digital media has ushers into newsrooms across the UK, the list would quickly become long.

The one I want to focus on today is the change in audience expectation and behaviour. Gone are the days when post-publication interaction with readers was confined to conversations with those who had the motivation to ring the newsdesk, visit ‘front counter’ or get their pen and paper out.

Since the victory by Donald Trump in the American elections, many millions of words online have been devoted to how the media Stateside got it so wrong, and what that means for the future of journalism.

I feel that’s coming at the problem from the wrong end. Digital platforms have given everyone a voice. Personalisation on those platforms – primarily through algorithms – has created a bubble-like experience for many people. I’m convinced the shock of the ‘exit’ vote in Brexit for many was worsened by that platforms like Facebook so effectively target what you see that Brexit-supporters were all but banished from Remainers timelines, and vice versa.

That bubble-like environment, and the ease with which people can now publish a view, puts a new spotlight on what people are thinking about what they are reading. This isn’t a Facebook thing. Any football writer whose club is also served by a fans forum where every story is analysed, reacted to and commented upon will know what I’m talking about. Everyone has a voice, and many are critics.

Overall, this is a positive thing. At least people care enough about what we’re writing to talk about it. Irrelevance-induced silence must be worse.

(more…)

FOI: A hospital’s shameful secret, and the pathetic attempts to keep the public in the dark

The Manchester Evening New broke a story on Wednesday night which was result of months of hard work. It was a story which should chill the bones of any parent living in North Manchester, or any journalist who believes that those running hospitals should do so in an open and transparent way.

I’m not alone in falling into both categories on this one. It’s a story which shames the NHS, and shames the people who tried to keep a lid on it – the very people who were sent into a hospital because it was deemed to be failing. The fact they tried to keep the scale of those failings out of the public domain should shock us all.

By now, you’ve probably heard of the story. Social Affairs Editor Jennifer Williams got hold of a review into maternity services at hospitals run by the Pennine Hospitals Trust. It was a report which contained findings including:

(more…)

The Second City Derby and the other problem with Facebook Trending

33904_cooldnn20facebook20like

The ‘Second City Derby’ took place yesterday – between Aston Villa and Birmingham City. Having worked with the Birmingham Mail for almost a decade, I now understand why so many fans of the two sides get so frustrated with the national media’s attitude to the city’s football clubs.

You don’t need to spend a long time with fans of Blues, Villa, West Brom (not in Birmingham I know) and other Midlands teams to know that they are as passionate as any other set of fans, so the constant referencing by radio commentators and media pundits to the ‘passion on show’ from the fans always suggests more about how much Midlands football is ignored most of the time than anything else.

It made an appearance in the Facebook Trending box on my timeline today too – or rather, a reference to Gary Gardner, who scored for Villa, appeared.

(more…)

How a ‘slow news week’ can separate the local Press stars from the critics on the sidelines

 

latimesnewspaper

One of the myths swirling around Hackademia these days – and among many commentators who have exited day-to-day life within the regional press – is that focusing on audience analytics somehow undermines quality journalism.

And of course, there is a risk of that being the case. It depends on how you use the metrics. But a point made by Ian Carter, the editorial director of Kent Messenger group this week, reminded me that in many ways, there’s nothing new under the regional Press sun.

Yes, the platforms have changed. Yes, the audiences have changed. Yes, the habits of readers have changed (something many of the naysayers overlook). But the risk of being too internally focused at the expense of serving readers is no more likely than it was in the days of print.

(more…)

Two charts which show the regional press has challenges – but credibility isn’t one of them

Another week, another academic popping up to shout ‘CLICKBAIT’ and ‘LISTICLES’ and heralding the end of local journalism as we know it – or perhaps how they remember it.

Maybe I shouldn’t rise to the bait, but then again, I’m quite opinionated. And I’m happy to debate the approach the newsrooms I work with take to local news in the 21st century with anyone who cares about the role of the local Press in challenged times.

But when I see Holdthefrontpage leading with the claims of an academic – this time a chap called Sean Dodson, of Leeds Beckett University – which are so outlandish (but I guess make for a good headline) I think it’s important to respond with facts. He’s published part of a chapter he’s written for a forthcoming book about how the local press survives as print declines.

(more…)